If you’re facing court-martial, you may be wondering: Do my constitutional rights still apply? Despite popular belief, many of the constitutional rights that apply at a civilian criminal prosecution apply equally to a court-martial prosecution. Below is an overview of some of those rights.
An accused at a court-martial is presumed innocent. Further, the burden of proof is on the government, i.e., the prosecution. The burden never shifts to an accused.
In order for an accused to be convicted, the prosecution’s evidence must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
An accused can take the stand and testify on their own behalf, subject to cross-examination by the prosecutor. Conversely, an accused has an absolute right to remain silent. An accused’s silence at a court-martial cannot be held against them in any way by the judge or jury. To learn more about an accused’s right to remain silent, visit our page on Article 31.
An accused at a court-martial usually has the right to confront the witnesses against them pursuant to the Sixth Amendment Confrontation Clause.
Although there are some nuances unique to the military, the protection against unreasonable searches and seizures generally applies. Thus, probable cause is often times needed before military authorities can search or seize something. This mainly applies to an accused’s own person, i.e., their body, and their personal belongings.
An accused has a constitutional right to have an attorney at a court-martial (subject to very limited exceptions). Further, an accused has a right to be represented by counsel of their choice at their expense. In other words, if you can afford it, you can have any attorney you want representing you.
The above list is by no means exhaustive. Other constitutional rights apply as well, such as rights pertaining to coerced confessions. The important thing is to have counsel who can navigate these issues.
YOU HAVE THE RIGHT TO HIRE AN ATTORNEY OF YOUR CHOICE
Facing a court-martial can be an overwhelming experience. Sometimes things move extremely fast and it’s like a blur. Other times, the investigation is painfully slow and fosters crippling anxiety. No matter what, it is important to have someone in your corner who you can trust. Someone who can advocate for you. And someone who isn’t afraid to stand-up against long odds.
As a former active duty JAG officer and two-time defense counsel in the Air Force, Ross Brennan at Cronauer Law is a seasoned advocate in military court rooms. Contact Cronauer Law today for a free consultation with an experienced military criminal defense attorney.
To learn more about a court-martial in the military, see these related links: